When planning your financial future, it’s essential to compare various investment options to determine which best aligns with your risk tolerance, financial goals, and liquidity needs.
This guide breaks down how Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs) compare to Money Market Accounts (MMAs), Certificates of Deposit (CDs), and High-Yield Savings Accounts (HYSAs) in terms of safety, returns, liquidity, and other important considerations.
Money Market Accounts (MMAs) vs. Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs)
Safety
MMAs: Generally very safe and are FDIC or NCUA insured up to $250,000 per depositor. This ensures that even if the bank or credit union fails, your money is protected.
FIAs: Backed by the financial strength of the issuing insurance company so it’s important to choose a highly-rated carrier, offering a high degree of safety but lacking federal insurance.
Returns
MMAs: Typically offer modest returns, generally higher than regular savings accounts but lower than CDs and HYSAs. The returns fluctuate with interest rates dictated by the market.
FIAs: Offer higher potential returns compared to MMAs, as they are linked to the performance of a market index like the S&P 500. They also provide guaranteed minimum interest rates, shielding you from market losses.
Liquidity
MMAs: Offer excellent liquidity, allowing you to access your funds without penalty. However, they typically limit the number of withdrawals you can make per month.
FIAs: Usually come with surrender periods during which withdrawals may incur penalties. Surrender charges typically decrease over time, but early access to funds can be restricted.
Other Considerations
MMAs: Ideal for short-term savings needs due to their high liquidity.
FIAs: Better suited for long-term financial planning, particularly for those looking to secure retirement income with some growth tied to the stock market.
Certificates of Deposit (CDs) vs. Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs)
Safety
CDs: Very safe investments, insured up to $250,000 per depositor by the FDIC or NCUA, ensuring that your principal is protected.
FIAs: Rely on the financial health of the issuing insurer (so make sure to choose a highly-rated carrier) and do not carry federal insurance; instead, state guaranty associations may offer some level of protection.
Returns
CDs: Offer fixed returns over a specified term, usually ranging from a few months to several years. Longer terms generally provide higher interest rates.
FIAs: Have the potential for higher returns compared to CDs, as they are tied to stock market index performance. They also guarantee a minimum interest rate, making them potentially more lucrative without exposing your principal to market losses.
Liquidity
CDs: Have predetermined terms and impose penalties for early withdrawal, making them less liquid compared to MMAs and HYSAs.
FIAs: Also have surrender periods during which withdrawals may incur penalties. These penalties typically decrease over time, making early access less desirable.
Other Considerations
CDs: Excellent for investors seeking predictable, stable returns over a fixed period.
FIAs: Ideal for individuals looking for long-term growth opportunities without sacrificing the safety of their principal.
High-Yield Savings Accounts (HYSAs) vs. Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs)
Safety
HYSAs: Among the safest savings vehicles, being FDIC or NCUA insured up to $250,000 per depositor.
FIAs: Backed by the issuing insurance company's solvency, offering strong safety but without federal insurance.
Returns
HYSAs: Offer higher interest rates than standard savings accounts, and these rates can fluctuate with market conditions.
FIAs: Can potentially offer higher returns than HYSAs, as their performance is linked to a market index. They also offer a guaranteed minimum interest rate, ensuring that your principal is protected from market downturns.
Liquidity
HYSAs: Provide superior liquidity, allowing you to withdraw funds without penalties. However, there are usually limits on the number of withdrawals per month.
FIAs: Have liquidity constraints due to surrender periods and associated penalties for early withdrawals. These penalties decrease over time, making liquidity less immediate.
Other Considerations
HYSAs: Well-suited for an emergency fund or short-term savings goals due to their high liquidity and safety.
FIAs: Better for long-term financial goals, such as retirement planning, offering growth potential tied to market performance without exposing your principal to market downturns.
Conclusion
Choosing between Fixed Indexed Annuities, Money Market Accounts, CDs, and High-Yield Savings Accounts depends on your individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and need for liquidity.
FIAs offer the potential for higher returns with guaranteed principal protection, making them a solid choice for long-term savings and retirement planning. MMAs, CDs, and HYSAs provide varying degrees of safety, returns, and liquidity, catering more to short-term savings and conservative investment strategies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Both are considered safe, but they work differently. CDs and savings accounts are federally insured up to $250,000. Fixed Indexed Annuities rely on the financial strength of the insurance company, offering strong protection but without FDIC insurance.
No, your principal is protected from market losses. However, early withdrawals may incur surrender charges or penalties.
Potentially, yes. Fixed Indexed Annuities can provide higher returns because they’re linked to a stock market index, while high-yield savings rates are based on bank interest rates and can change frequently.
Generally no. FIAs are better suited for long-term financial goals like retirement planning due to surrender periods and limited liquidity.
People looking for long-term growth, principal protection, and future retirement income may benefit most from an FIA, especially if they don’t need immediate access to the money.
Ready to take the next step?
More to read
How to rollover funds into an annuity
Annuities offer more options and market protection compared to a 401(k), making them an attractive choice for retirement planning. Understanding the rollover process from a 401(k), 403(b), or IRA to an annuity is crucial to avoid penalties and tax implications. This guide provides clear steps to help you navigate the rollover process smoothly.
Are annuities taxable? What you need to know.
Annuities can be funded with either pre-tax (qualified) or post-tax (non-qualified) dollars, each offering different tax benefits and considerations. Whether you're rolling an old 401(k) or simply using a checking account, you'll learn all about taxation.
Comparing Annuities to Employer-Sponsored Plans (401(k) and 403(b))
Annuities offer protected growth and tax-deferred advantages, providing a safe way to accumulate wealth with less exposure to market volatility. In contrast, 401(k)s and 403(b)s offer greater investment flexibility and potentially higher returns, supplemented by employer contributions.
Who we are
Reducing retirement risk
once and for all.
5.0
Resources
Copyright ©2025 Revise. All rights reserved.
Insurance products offered through Revise Insurance Group LLC (domicile IL #3002790618; CA d/b/a Revise Insurance Solutions #6012761).
Revise Insurance Group LLC is NOT a registered investment adviser and does NOT provide advice regarding the purchase, sale, or holding of securities.
Any references to “portfolio,” “return,” or “performance” on this site relate solely to the performance of insurance products—primarily fixed indexed annuities (“FIAs”)—and are illustrative only.
FIAs are insurance contracts, not bank deposits; they are not FDIC- or NCUA-insured, and guarantees are subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer. Product values may be reduced by surrender charges, market-value adjustments, or other contract provisions. Read the policy and all riders carefully.
Content on this site is for general educational purposes and should not be construed as personalized investment, legal, or tax advice. Past or hypothetical performance does not guarantee future results.
Logos or trademarks of third-party publications (e.g., Forbes®, Inc.®, MarketWatch®) are the property of their respective owners and do not imply endorsement. Services are offered only where Revise Insurance Group LLC is properly licensed; not all products are available in every state.